Villa’s Tommy Hughes helped stop rock-bottom Brighton rot

BRIGHTON were in a sorry state floundering at the bottom of the old Second Division when manager Pat Saward turned to a former Aston Villa teammate to borrow his back-up goalkeeper.

Albion had gone on a horrendous run of 14 consecutive defeats between November and February in the 1972-73 season and Saward decided to take regular custodian Brian Powney out of the firing line.

Inexperienced reserve goalkeeper Alan Dovey had twice conceded four goals (in defeats at Preston and Sunderland) during that awful run and between him and Powney they’d conceded 37 goals.

After seeing Albion succumb 3-1 at home to Villa and 5-1 at Fulham, Saward had a word with Vic Crowe, a former Villa teammate who by then was in the manager’s chair at Villa Park, and got him to agree a loan move for Tommy Hughes.

Hughes, who had spent years in Peter Bonetti’s shadow at Chelsea, arrived on the south coast to try to stem the tide and help Brighton get back on the winning trail.

His first run-out for the Albion came in a home friendly against then First Division Stoke City – both sides had been knocked out of the previous round of the FA Cup. Saward also gave a debut to 17-year-old Tony Towner although, unfortunately, Albion were once again on the losing side, 2-0. Nevertheless, the Albion matchday programme said Hughes “had a storming game”.

The losing streak finally came to an end the following Saturday when Hughes made his league debut at home to Luton Town. As well as the change in goal, Saward stuck with Towner on the wing and put another teenager, Pat Hilton, up front alongside Ken Beamish who scored both Albion goals in a 2-0 win.

Unsurprisingly, Hughes kept the shirt for two more league matches, a 3-1 defeat at Bristol City and a 2-0 reverse at Hull City.

Sandwiched between those games, he appeared in a Friday night friendly against visiting Moscow Spartak on 23 February which Albion won 1-0; captain Ian Goodwin scoring the only goal of the game.

Saward wanted to sign Hughes permanently but the powers-that-be couldn’t come up with the required fee and Powney resumed his place. Although Albion put up a bit of a fight, only losing two of the remaining 11 games, winning five and drawing four, the damage had already been done over the winter and they were relegated along with Huddersfield Town.

Hughes at Hereford

Hughes, meanwhile, returned to Villa Park but was soon on the move to a permanent home, where he stayed for many years.

Transferred to Hereford United in August 1973 for £15,000, he became something of a club legend and stayed in the area apart from one brief return to Scotland.

As the official club website noted: “He was an immediate success at Hereford and won the Player of the Year award in his first season and repeated the feat five seasons later.”

Manager Colin Addison brought him in when David Icke, the conspiracy theorist and former BBC sports broadcaster, was forced to retire through injury and regular no.1 Fred Potter was also sidelined.

Hughes made 240 appearances over nine seasons with The Bulls, and was in their Third Division championship-winning side of 1975-76. He later became Hereford’s caretaker manager during the 1982-83 season.

In 2006, he demonstrated his prowess at golf when he became the Herefordshire County Senior Champion. Posting a gross score of 72 at the Sapey course, the local newspaper said he had “produced a championship winning round in tricky conditions”. It added: “The course was beautifully manicured but many competitiors struggled to cope with the extra run and bounce off fairways baked hard after weeks of relentless sunshine.”

Born in Dalmuir, West Dunbartonshire, on 11 July 1947, Hughes started out with Scottish Second Division side Clydebank before Tommy Docherty signed him for Chelsea in 1966.

Only ever an understudy to Bonetti, he played two league games in each of 1966-67 and 1967-68, once in 1968-69 and six times in 1969-70.

His competitive debut came on 19 November 1966, when he was only 19, in a 1-1 Stamford Bridge draw against Sheffield United.

The following month he shipped six as Chelsea were thumped 6-1 at Sheffield Wednesday on New Year’s Eve.

In 1968, he was in the Chelsea side that won 5-3 at Southampton and 2-1 at Sheffield United.

In the six games he played between January and April 1970, he conceded 15 goals which included five goals in front of 57,221 at home to Leeds and five to Everton (who went on to win the First Division title) when 57,828 packed in to Goodison Park. Everton were 2-0 up (through Howard Kendall and Alan Ball) within five minutes of the start!

During his time at Chelsea, he was twice selected to play for the Scotland under 23 side. He made his debut on 3 December 1969 in a 4-0 win over France.

The following March he was between the sticks when the England under 23s beat the Scots 3-1 at Roker Park (his Chelsea teammate Peter Osgood scored twice, Brian Kidd the other) but the game was abandoned on 62 minutes when a snowstorm made it impossible to play the full 90 minutes.

His last game for Chelsea came the following month, on 15 April 1970, when Burnley beat the London side 3–1 at Turf Moor.

After Hughes broke his leg in a pre-season friendly in Holland, manager Dave Sexton brought in John Phillips from Villa to understudy Bonetti and, the following May, the displaced Hughes moved in the opposite direction, for £12,500. Phillips would later spend the 1980-81 season as Albion’s back-up goalkeeper under Alan Mullery.

Hughes might have thought he had finally claimed a no.1 spot of his own in a Villa side that had just been relegated to the third tier. He made his Third Division debut at home to Plymouth Argyle on 14 August.

But he only played 16 games under Vic Crowe before losing his place to Jim Cumbes, who had signed from West Brom. Cumbes was one of those rare breeds of sportsmen who also played county cricket for Lancashire, Surrey, Worcestershire and Warwickshire.

Hughes’ 23rd and last game for Villa saw him make a horrible blunder in a first round FA Cup match at Fourth Division Southend United in November 1971. He dropped a free kick at the feet of Bill Garner (who later moved to Chelsea) who set up Billy Best to score the only goal of the game for the Shrimpers.

The ‘keeper’s long run as Hereford’s first choice came to an end in the 1977-78 season, when new signing Peter Mellor, once of Burnley and Fulham, took over the gloves.

Hughes decided to return to Scotland and signed a one-month contract with Dundee United. He contemplated moving his family back up north permanently, but they wanted to return to Hereford, which they did.

“The club and the fans welcomed him back with open arms and Tommy remained at Edgar Street until he finally hung up his boots in 1982,” said the club website. “Tommy never lost his love for Hereford and jumped at the chance of having spells as commercial manager and even as caretaker manager when the financial situation at Edgar Street was fraught.”

As it turned out, he was to make one final appearance at Edgar Street in the 1983-84 Radio Wyvern Cup Final. He had attended as a spectator but turned out for Worcester City after their ‘keeper Paul Hayward dislocated a finger in the pre-match warm up.

Hughes had a spell as manager of Trowbridge Town but his home remained in Hereford where he ran his own successful carpet-cleaning business for many years.

Goals dried up at Brighton for Pompey favourite Alan Biley

1 150th goal v Leeds (1-1)ALAN BILEY was a fans favourite at all six English league clubs he played for but the prolific goalscoring that made his name at Cambridge United and Portsmouth wasn’t replicated at Everton or Brighton.

His spiky, long blond hair reflected his devotion to singer Rod Stewart and, on the pitch, the way he wore his football shirt outside his shorts, clutched the cuffs, and saluted a goal with a raised forefinger was a tribute to Scottish footballing legend Denis Law, another of his heroes, .

Biley was quite the hero at Portsmouth, with a goalscoring record of more than a goal every other game, having been signed by Bobby Campbell in 1982.

But when he fell out of favour with Campbell’s successor, Alan Ball, Brighton’s Chris Cattlin stepped in and paid £50,000 to take the striker along the coast in March 1985.

Within a month of the move, he was back at Fratton Park in Albion’s colours for an Easter Saturday south coast derby when honours were even in a 1-1 draw.

Biley had made his Seagulls debut as a substitute for Frank Worthington in a 0-0 draw away to Barnsley, then got his first start the following game (another goalless draw, at home to Oxford) and kept his place to the end of the season.

The first of four goals during that spell came in a 2-0 win at home to Oldham, and the goal he scored in a 1-1 home draw with Leeds on 20 April was his 150th in league football (top picture).  Although Albion finished with three wins, it wasn’t enough to reach the promotion places, and they finished sixth.

Biley made a great start to the 1985-86 campaign, scoring against First Division Nottingham Forest in a remarkable 5-1 pre-season friendly win, and then in the opening league fixture, a 2-2 home draw with Grimsby Town.

However, competition for places in Albion’s forward line had intensified. In addition to Terry Connor, £1m man Justin Fashanu arrived together with Dean Saunders, on a free transfer from Swansea, (Saunders went on to be named player of the season).

With the much-derided Mick Ferguson also managing a brief purple patch of scoring, it meant Biley struggled to hold down a regular spot, making 24 starts plus three appearances as a sub, and only managing to add three more goals to that season’s opener.

Cattlin’s dismissal as boss, to be replaced by the returning Alan Mullery, also spelled the end of Biley’s time at the club. He initially went back to Cambridge on loan, then tried his luck with New York Express in the States, had a spell in Greece before ending up in Ireland, playing for Waterford who were managed by his old Everton teammate, Andy King. He ended up back at Cambridge on a non-contract basis in November 1988 and made three more appearances for United before hanging up his boots.

But let’s go back to the beginning. Born in Leighton Buzzard on 26 February 1957, Biley was spotted by nearby Luton Town at the tender age of 10 and signed schoolboy forms aged 12. He was then offered an apprenticeship and professional forms as he worked his way through the different levels. But financial issues hit the club and when their chief scout left to link up with Cambridge, he recommended Biley to manager Ron Atkinson, and in 1975 he made the move to Fourth Division United.

Biley netted a total of 82 in 185 games as United rose from the Fourth Division to the Second between 1975 and 1979, when his eye for goal caught the attention of First Division Derby County, who paid £450,000 for his services.

Biley continued to find the net regularly in the top flight, scoring nine in 18 games for the Rams, but he couldn’t prevent them from being relegated. He stuck with them in the 1980-81 season and scored 10 playing in the second tier but was sidelined through injury for several months.

He recounted recently how he fell out with manager Colin Addison and there was talk of him being sold to West Brom, where his old boss Atkinson had moved, but instead, in July 1981, he became new Everton manager Howard Kendall’s first signing for a £300,000 fee. Everton fans who go back that far refer to the Magnificent Seven – because that’s how many players Kendall signed in a short space of time.

Biley EVEBiley was an instant hit, scoring on his Everton debut as Birmingham City were beaten 3-1. He scored again in his next game away to Leeds, but things quickly started to go wrong for him, as he explained in great detail to Everton fan website bluekipper.com.

“I was always appreciative of the Evertonians’ footballing knowledge and the support and gusto, particularly through the tough times,” said Biley. “They were very loyal through the tough times, and they are a different class.

“I would like to think they took to me but my only big regret was that I wasn’t there long enough to enjoy them.”

By October, Kendall had dropped his new signing and Biley was mystified.

“Years later, as I look back at it, I wasn’t Howard Kendall’s cup of tea. Whatever that was, I can’t put my finger on it because history tells you what I was and what I did and where I played, and he had a different opinion of that.

“I would have loved him to have had the faith in me he had in lots of other players.”

Eventually his lack of involvement in first team action saw him go out on loan to struggling Stoke City and in eight games he helped them to retain their status in the top division, but hopes of a permanent move fell through.

Instead he departed Goodison Park with just 18 appearances (plus three as sub) and three goals to his name and dropped down to the Third Division with Portsmouth.

The Pompey faithful had already had a taste of what they could expect when, at Christmas 1977, as a 20-year-old playing for Cambridge, Biley had scored twice for table-topping Cambridge at Fratton Park.

And, sure enough, when paired up front with Billy Rafferty, he became an instant hit and the duo scored 40 between them as Pompey won promotion. Biley’s performances earned him a place in the PFA select XI that included Gillingham’s Steve Bruce and Micky Adams, Portsmouth colleague Neil Webb and Kerry Dixon, then of Reading.

The following season saw Biley gain a new strike partner in the shape of Mark Hateley, who would go on to earn England international recognition. However, a series of 10 home defeats put paid to their promotion hopes and Campbell was sacked on the coach on the way back from the season’s penultimate game at Derby. In the final game of the season, with Alan Ball in temporary charge, Biley hit a hat-trick in a 5-0 demolition of Swansea.

Ball was installed as manager and Biley was very much a part of the side that began the 1984-85 season. He played in 22 games and came off the bench twice, scoring a total of 13 goals before Ball mysteriously sold him to Brighton in March.

Biley’s heart never left Fratton Park, though, and in 2015 he told Neil Allen, the author of a book Played Up Pompey: “Pompey was – and still is – my club.

“Pompey was a three-year box in time and if I could possibly open that box again and recover moments, a day even, then I would die happy. I fell in love with the club and it has never gone away.”

Biley has revelled in many opportunities to reminisce about his playing days, attending numerous reunions and enjoying all the memories.

In June 2017, he got together with other former players to talk about his goalscoring days at Cambridge and in October 2017, broadcaster and Albion fan Peter Brackley helped a number of former Pompey players, including Biley, recall a famous occasion when a fan ran on the pitch dressed as Santa Claus and, after the disruption, Biley scored two late goals to win a dramatic cup tie against Oxford.

But in all my research for this piece, I could find no loving references to his time with the Albion, although five years ago the excellent thegoldstonewrap.com brought together some footage of some of his best moments.

After his playing days were over, he moved back to his Bedfordshire roots and got involved in non-league football with various sides in and around the Home Counties, alongside running his own gym in Biggleswade.

  • Pictures from the Albion programme / Evening Argus and various online sources.