Bold McShane’s return to scene of memorable Brighton win

PAUL McSHANE’S move to Selhurst Park at the beginning of 2012 was quite bold considering he had memorably scored a winner for Brighton on that ground on 18 October 2005.

But did he actually get the final touch on the goal that gave the Seagulls their first win at Selhurst Park in more than 20 years?

McShane launches himself at Seb Carole’s corner and was credited with getting a touch on Albion’s winner at Selhurst

‘McShane 78 minutes’ went into the record books and it certainly looked like he’d got his head, or maybe his shoulder, on the ball as it went into the box from Seb Carole’s corner.

But Albion’s skipper Charlie Oatway offered some playful banter about it in his matchday programme column for the following home game.

“Paul McShane claimed he scored the goal, but he is fibbing,” said Charlie. “Seb’s corner went over my head and as I turned round I saw Emerson Boyce head it. Fair play to the compulsive liar though for actually having the front to go on TV and radio and claim it, saying ‘I managed to get something on it’.

Guy Butters credits McShane with that winner

“After hearing about the number of fans who won thousands of pounds betting on the 1-0 scoreline and ‘Ginger’ scoring the winning goal, all the lads reckon he’s on a percentage of the take!”

McShane salutes the delighted Albion fans

Such was the enormity of the result at that time that each player’s white shirt from that evening was put up for auction by the club with fans bidding hundreds of pounds for the sweaty mementoes!

The club also produced 1,260 limited edition versions of the then one-off shirt embroidered with the match date and score and they released a DVD ‘One Night at the Palace’ for fans to remember it by.

“Crystal Palace was a special night, because of the rivalry,” said McShane. “It was a great atmosphere and scoring that goal was brilliant.”

Fast forward six and a bit years and, with McShane out of favour at Hull, Palace took him on loan to Selhurst and, as if the fates would have it, one of his first appearances for the Eagles was in a 1-1 draw against Brighton – making their first return to Croydon since that 2005 victory.

One of McShane’s first Palace games was against Brighton

On January transfer deadline day 2012, the game finished with honours even, although Inigo Calderon came close to snatching another win in stoppage time.

It proved to be a game of two penalties, both involving Albion winger Will Buckley. After Wilfred Zaha went down in the box under Buckley’s challenge, Chris Martin netted from 12 yards for Palace in the 64th minute.

At the other end, ten minutes later, Buckley was fouled in the penalty area by Nathaniel Clyne and Ashley Barnes equalised from the spot for the Albion.

Shortly afterwards, McShane’s loan was extended until the end of the season and he told yourlocalguardian: “I am enjoying my time here and I was hoping I would be able to stay until the end of the season.

“I have to be playing as many games as I can if I am going to get in the (Republic of Ireland) squad for the Euros and I just needed to get away from Hull as I wasn’t getting a chance to play in a regular spot.”

Palace’s first choice central defensive pairing were Anthony Gardner and Paddy McCarthy, but McShane said: “It is good to have a bit of competition and I will be pushing them all way.”

The temporary move worked out as he’d hoped after he made nine appearances (plus three as a sub) in Dougie Freeman’s side in their 17th place finish in the Championship table, seven places below Brighton.

He was included in Giovanni Trapattoni’s squad for the 2012 Euros although he didn’t get a game as the Irish fell to three defeats in Group C, to Croatia, Spain and Italy.

McShane had made his full international debut six years earlier (against the Czech Republic at Lansdowne Road) and he recalled: “The atmosphere was amazing. I was up against Jan Koller, who was about 6ft 8in, so I decided to give him a right bash. I ended up getting man of the match.”

He won 29 of his caps by the time he was 24 and scored an own goal on the stroke of half-time in his 33rd and final appearance for his country, a 2-2 draw with Slovakia in March 2016 (by which time he’d moved on to Reading).

The Palace loan was his second successive temporary spell away from Hull: in February 2011, he joined a Barnsley side who had his old Man Utd and West Brom teammate Luke Steele in goal and one-time Albion loanee Diego Arismendi in midfield.

The last of his 10 games for the Tykes had come on 17 April 2011 when he was sent off for violent conduct after 69 minutes of a 1-1 draw at Middlesbrough.

But his time on Humberside was not up, because, when Steve Bruce took over as manager at Hull in June 2012, McShane returned to the City fold. Fans of a certain vintage also remember it was his goal against Cardiff on the final day of the 2012-13 season that took the Tigers back up to the Premier League. He went on to hold down a regular place in the top flight for two seasons.

McShane wasn’t in the Hull side that beat Brighton 2-1 in a FA Cup fifth round replay in 2014, after a 1-1 draw at the Amex, nor the one that beat Sunderland 3-0 in the quarter-finals, but he got on as a substitute in the final when Arsenal overturned the Tigers’ early lead to win the game 3-2 after extra time.

“I’d been injured but got back just before the final,” said McShane. “It was a sickener to lose in extra time after being in such a good position.”

In a retrospective piece for the Hull Daily Mail in March 2020, Philip Buckingham recounted: “McShane was an extraordinary figure during an association that spanned seven campaigns at the KCOM Stadium. His talent and technique failed to elevate him above team-mates, but the defender’s perseverance and drive encountered few rivals.

“McShane found the resolve to conjure more comebacks than Frank Sinatra. Nigel Pearson, Nick Barmby and Steve Bruce all swung the exit door open, encouraging McShane to move on, but on every occasion he came bouncing back to prominence. Only when his contract expired with City condemned to the Championship (in 2015) did he finally reach the end of the road.”

McShane told the reporter: “The beauty was in the struggle. And there was a lot of struggle.

“But that’s why the relationship between me and the club grew so strong. There were some tough times but I always had a feeling I could turn it around. I suppose I did in the end.”

McShane ended up making a total of 136 appearances for Hull, and he reflected: “It was the best times of my football career but also the worst times as well, to be honest.

“There were some difficult moments in there but that was the beauty of it all. I think the bond was strong because I was on the journey with everyone.

“Every time I stepped on the pitch I gave my all. It sounds silly but I would probably die on the pitch to be honest with you.

“That’s just the way I’ve always played the game and just the way I am. Football is everything to me. Competing is everything to me and the fans recognised that.

“But every time I thought I was getting somewhere, I was always hit with another setback. It was difficult and at times I wanted to give up in all honesty.

“And that was to give up football, not just being at Hull City. I was just so fed up with the setbacks. But I saw it out. I never gave up.”

His final Hull appearance was in a 0-0 Premier League draw at home to Manchester United, and reflecting on the end of his turbulent Tigers tenure, he told the Hull paper’s Buckingham: “My career has been one long fight in a lot of ways.

“Even before I came over from Ireland, you’d have people tell you that not many made it, only one per cent stay and make a career of it.

“I came over thinking they’d have to take me home in a body bag. There was not a chance I wasn’t going to make it. I was determined to do everything I possibly could to make it as a professional footballer.

“Sometimes I look back and think ‘Jesus, if I could’ve just relaxed a bit.’ I was maybe too tense about it all. Even in the youth team at Man United I was like a mad man, so determined to make it.

“I was always told I wasn’t big enough to be a centre-back. I was always told I wasn’t quick enough or I wasn’t good enough technically. So, I just kept on going to try and prove those people wrong. It meant so much to me.”

After a couple of seasons playing in League One for Rochdale, McShane returned to United as an academy coach but spent the 2025-26 season as an assistant coach at League One Huddersfield.

In July 2026, he was appointed first team coach at Lincoln City, who were newly-promoted to the Championship. He also coaches the Republic of Ireland under-21s.

“I think the ambition has to be to become a number one eventually,” he said. “But I always wanted to make sure I was ready for it rather than jumping straight in. I want to continue my football education and hopefully move into a job where I know I’ve covered every angle if I want to become a successful manager.”

Competition for places edged out midfielder Jamie Smith

DIMINUTIVE midfielder Jamie Smith spent 11 years at Crystal Palace, going through the youth ranks before signing as a pro, but didn’t play league football until he joined Brighton.

Russell Slade took on the 19-year-old during his brief reign in charge of the Seagulls (and signed the player again when he was in charge at Orient).

Albion picked up the discarded 5’6” Smith in the summer of 2009 and he did enough as a triallist in pre-season friendlies to be awarded a contract by the Seagulls.

Slade said: “Jamie has done exceptionally well throughout pre-season. He’s worked hard to convince us he is worth a contract and he has the potential to be a very good player.”

His first league start was memorable for all the wrong reasons. In only the third league game of the season, he was selected in midfield away to Huddersfield Town.

But when regular no.1 ‘keeper Michel Kuipers was sent off six minutes before half time, the young midfielder was sacrificed to allow substitute goalkeeper Graeme Smith to take over between the sticks. Depleted Albion then went on to succumb to a 7-1 battering.

“I had mixed feelings really,” he told the matchday programme. “It was great to make my debut and I thought we started the game well, but the sending off changed everything and it was all downhill from then on.”

It was Smith’s only start of the whole season. He was on the subs bench on half a dozen occasions but only went on in one of them, away to Wycombe Wanderers at the end of the year.

Gus Poyet had succeeded Slade by then and with Albion coasting at 5-2 – Glenn Murray having scored four of them – Smith replaced Dean Cox in stoppage time.

During the close season, Andrew Crofts was sold to Norwich City and Cox left for Orient, but new arrivals Radostin Kishishev and Matt Sparrow provided new competition for midfield places.

But Poyet reckoned there was something about Smith and enthused about an “outstanding” performance he’d delivered in a pre-season friendly at Burgess Hill. He told the Argus: “We really like him. He could be an interesting player for the future, I’m telling you. He has got some qualities we need to use a bit better.”

After also impressing in a pre-season game against Aberdeen, Smith was in the starting line-up for the opening game of the 2010-11 season, when Albion won 2-1 at Swindon (Sparrow scored twice on his debut).

He played the following two league matches too: a 2-2 draw home to Rochdale (although Smith was sacrificed on 54 minutes after Gordon Greer was sent off for punching Anthony Elding and Adam El-Abd was sent on to play in the centre of defence).

I was sat in the Leppings Lane end at Hillsborough seven days later when Smith retained his place in midfield against Sheffield Wednesday (above left).

The youngster even came closest to netting an equaliser for the Seagulls; his shot from Ashley Barnes’ cutback clipped the bar.

However, Albion then re-signed Kazenga LuaLua and Poyet reckoned Smith didn’t do enough to show he wanted it more than the explosive winger. “Because he is young, maybe he took it too nicely,” Poyet told the Argus. “I need people to react, to show me I have made a mistake or even to put me under pressure. He was just normal, not at his best to give me a headache to have to play him.”

Smith himself admitted: “When LuaLua)was playing I seemed to take it that he would be playing instead of me.

“Sometimes, when we were both on the bench, I used to think he would go on, not me, whereas I should have been doing everything I could to make sure I was involved. If I had the time again, I would have done things differently.

“I wouldn’t be one to go in and moan and stuff because there are always ups and downs in football but you can always go out every day and do your best and work hard.

“The season started really well for me, a lot better than I expected. I didn’t expect to be playing as much as I was but when that happens you just want more and I just want to be playing every week.

“Maybe when the team was doing really well, on a long unbeaten run, I was slacking off in training and things like that.”

The door opened ajar again after LuaLua suffered a broken leg and Smith impressed after going on as a 53rd-minute sub away to Southampton (below, left).

Smith told Andy Naylor: “LuaLua was class. He changed games when he came on and when he started he was really good. Hopefully I can do as well, if not better, than he was doing if I get the chance.

“We are really different players. He is really explosive with pace and loads of ability. I like trying to play clever little passes and making space for myself and my team-mates.”

One such cute pass at St Mary’s let in Glenn Murray to earn the Seagulls a penalty and the longstanding Albion reporter said: “The door is ajar for Smith again after that Southampton cameo and now he has to walk through it. His Albion future depends on it.”

Smith told the matchday programme: “I feel I’ve done well in most of the games I’ve played in and want to use the Southampton game as a platform for the rest of the season.

“The manager told me after that game that he wants me to give him performances like that all the time.”

Enjoying time in the limelight, the player explained: “I love to get the ball, drive forward and create chances.

“I am slight in size and most managers from the Championship downwards want strong, athletic midfielders but our manager wants footballers, players who get the ball down and play.

“As long as I’m on the ball and doing a job for the team, then the manager will be happy.”

Smith added: “I knew that if I didn’t progress this season there’s every chance I would be let go in the summer so I’ve been using that as an incentive.

“With the way the club has been progressing on the pitch and off it, there’s no way I want to leave. I want to stay here for years to come because I’m happy at the club.”

Unfortunately, the new year wasn’t even three weeks old when an accidental collision in training saw Smith sidelined for two months.

He sustained a fractured metatarsal after colliding with teammate Jake Forster-Caskey and, with his contract due to expire at the end of the season, the outlook was bleak.

But Poyet said: “I have already had a good chat with him. I told him not to worry and that we will look after him.

“He will be out until March but it is important he doesn’t feel under pressure to rush back because of his contract situation.

“I want him to make sure his foot is properly healed first, and then I expect we will see him back to fitness before the end of the season.”

Come the end of the season, Poyet was as good as his word and gave Smith a six-month contract to prove his worth.

But he wasn’t able to capitalise on the opportunity, Poyet saying: “Jamie was a revelation at the beginning of last season before we got Kazenga (LuaLua) back.

“Then he was injured for months and we were established at the top of the table, so he didn’t get the chance to play.

“I thought I would give him the chance to prove himself but it hasn’t really happened for him.”

Albion supporter ‘The Phantom’ on an Argus report of Smith’s imminent departure from the club wrote: “Shame it hasn’t worked out for Jamie Smith as showed at times that he had what it takes to be an influential attacking midfielder.

“Way too much competition in the squad now so best that he moves on. Surprised he has not been able to pick up a club so far.”

Eventually, former boss Slade offered him a chance at Orient, but he made just the one substitute appearance for the Os before dropping out of league football with Dover Athletic.

Born in Leytonstone, East London, on 16 September 1989, Smith was on Palace’s books from the age of eight to 19 and although he progressed through the ranks he didn’t get to make a competitive first team appearance.

Nevertheless, Palace under 18 coach Gary Issott said: “Jamie Smith is a diminutive attacking central midfielder in the mould of Eyal Berkovic.

“He is very clever and improved after a frustrating first year. He started this season well and, up until Christmas, his form was electric.”

He was involved in pre-season friendlies ahead of the 2008-09 season and scored the winner from the penalty spot after going on as a substitute in a 4-3 win over Aldershot. (Calvin Andrew, later an Albion loanee, made his debut for Palace in the same match).

But while Smith saw several of his contemporaries make it through to competitive first team action, such an elevation remained elusive for him.

“That was disappointing but we had the likes of Nick Carle and Neil Danns in my position and it was hard to break through,” he said. 

A year below him, the likes of Victor Moses and Nathaniel Clyne did progress. Smith said: “I spoke to Neil Warnock but he said there were experienced players ahead of me and couldn’t see me breaking into the team. We agreed it would be best for me to move on.”

Smith had a spell at Doncaster Rovers but returned to Palace to keep his fitness up before joining Brighton for pre-season training, and then being taken on after a successful trial of three or four weeks.